Rutter Bros Dairy INC Safety Record

DOT# 11707 · York, PA 17404 · 7177715968

A

Excellent safety record — scored 5/100 (lower is better). This carrier has one of the best inspection records on file.

Last inspected 09/20/2025

Grade based on FMCSA inspection, crash, and violation data. See methodology →

Vehicle OOS Rate 0/30 pts
Driver OOS Rate 0/20 pts
Crash Rate 5/30 pts
Fatal Crash Penalty 0/20 pts

Lower scores are better. How is this calculated?

According to FMCSA records, Rutter Bros Dairy INC (DOT# 11707) in York, Pennsylvania has 25 inspections on record with 8 violations and a 8.0% vehicle out-of-service rate and 1 crash. Safety grade: A (excellent safety record). Active common authority.

25 Inspections
8.0% Vehicle OOS Rate
1 Crashes
28 Power Units

An out-of-service (OOS) violation means a vehicle or driver was found unsafe to operate during a roadside inspection and was prohibited from continuing until the issue was corrected.

Vehicle OOS Rate 8.0%
Carrier: 8.0% (2 of 25) National: 23.2%
Driver OOS Rate 0.0%
Carrier: 0.0% (0 of 25) National: 6.4%
60% OOS rate better than 60% of carriers in Pennsylvania
30% crash rate better than 30% of carriers in Pennsylvania

FMCSA groups violations into Behavioral Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (BASICs). Each violation found during a roadside inspection is classified into a category that reflects the type of safety risk.

8 total violations across 25 inspections
2 violations resulted in out-of-service orders (25%)
Vehicle Maintenance
5
Unsafe Driving
3

FMCSA inspections range from Level 1 (full vehicle and driver examination) to Level 6 (enhanced motorcoach inspection). Level 1 is the most thorough; Levels 2 and 3 are walk-around and driver-only checks.

Inspected across 3 states: MD, PA, US
Level 1: 6 (24%) Level 2: 14 (56%) Level 3: 5 (20%)
1 of 5 recent inspections had vehicle out-of-service violations
Date State Level Veh OOS Drv OOS
09/20/2025 MD 2 0 0
04/09/2025 MD 1 0 0
04/08/2025 PA 2 2 0
04/01/2025 MD 1 0 0
03/25/2025 US 1 0 0
02/26/2025 PA 3 0 0
02/14/2025 MD 2 0 0
11/20/2024 MD 2 0 0
11/13/2024 PA 3 0 0
10/19/2024 MD 2 0 0
1 injury crash
16-SEP-24 most recent crash on record
Date State Fatalities Injuries Tow-Aways
16-SEP-24 MD 0 1 0

FMCSA operating authority permits interstate for-hire transportation. Carriers must maintain minimum insurance coverage levels to keep authority active. BIPD (bodily injury and property damage) insurance is required for all for-hire carriers.

MC/MX Number MC262706
Common Authority Active
Contract Authority N
Broker Authority N
BIPD Insurance Not On File
Cargo Insurance Not On File
Surety Bond Not On File
Type Insurer Coverage Effective
BIPD/Primary Zurich American Insurance Company $750 01/01/2006

Power units include trucks, tractors, and other commercial motor vehicles registered to the carrier. Driver count reflects the total number of drivers reported on the carrier's MCS-150 filing.

Power Units 28
Drivers 32
Fleet Size Mid-Size Fleet
Operation Type Interstate
Hazmat No
Operating Since 06/01/1974
MCS-150 Filed 20250609 1
Annual Mileage (MCS-150) 1,177,618
Address 2100 N George Street, York, PA 17404